Although the series has been praised for addressing serious topics in a way that’s suitable for younger readers, recent criticism of the author has divided the fanbase.
The controversy started in 2019 when Rowling publically supported a researcher who lost her job over comments about transgender issues. In 2020, Rowling’s own comments on gender identity intensified the backlash when in regards to post that used the phrase, “people who menstruate”, Rowling remarked; “I’m sure there used to be a word for those people. Someone help me out. Wumben? Wimpund? Woomud?”
Many have accused her of insensitivity stating that she is oversimplifying womanhood to a singular biological function, thereby disregarding the experiences of transgender and non-binary individuals.
Others argue that there is a distinction between being critical of trans issues and advocating for women’s rights.
Writer Valentijin De Hingh, who is transgender and a Harry Potter fan, expressed surprise at Rowling’s stance, but acknowledged, “I do see her point, because her concerns about women’s safety are real.” To that point, Rowling has emphasized the importance of safety for everyone, stating, “Trans people need and deserve protection,” and affirming, “I respect every trans person’s right to live any way that feels authentic and comfortable to them.”
Opinions on Rowling’s position vary widely, ranging from mild criticism to outright condemnation to full support. Nevertheless, despite these differing views, there is a broad consensus among free speech advocates that the censorship she has faced crosses a line.
In a New York Times article titled “In Defense of J.K. Rowling,” Pamela Paul argues, “This campaign against Rowling is as dangerous as it is absurd. The brutal stabbing of Salman Rushdie is a stark reminder of the consequences of demonizing writers. Furthermore, characterizing her as a transphobe does not align with her actual views.”
Aligning Activism and Artist Expression
Even PEN America, a membership-based organization dedicated to protecting free expression at the intersection of literature and human rights, is currently facing internal conflict. The organization recently canceled major events due to disagreements among its members about the extent of its advocacy. These cancellations came after an unprecedented number of authors withdrew their work from award considerations and festival participation, arguing that PEN has not provided sufficient support, particularly in not advocating strongly enough for a cease-fire in Gaza. Meanwhile, other authors are choose to distance themselves from any controversy altogether.
In contrast, J.K. Rowling is an artist who integrates her personal views with her work. In April, she launched an “arrest me” challenge to protest Scotland’s new “hate crime” laws related to free speech. Both Rowling, the author of the Harry Potter series, and the owner of the social media platform X, argue that the legislation could negatively impact free speech.”
Despite this, there’s still a lot happening in the world of Harry Potter. HBO is working on a new TV series, and Audible is set to release an audiobook adaptation which was recorded with the original series actors’ voices.
Adding to this lineup is “From the Wizarding Archive,” an eBook and audiobook coming out in August. The new book features 80 articles and stories about the Harry Potter universe, offering deeper insights into favorite characters like Professor McGonagall and Remus Lupin. Evanna Lynch, who played Luna Lovegood in the films, will be one of the narrators.
While it’s not a new novel, “From the Wizarding Archive” promises longtime fans detailed background stories and additional context from the series. Set for release in English on August 29, 2024, the new project contains 80 articles and anecdotes about the world of Harry Potter. Included in the treasure trove are backstories on major characters and additional context on the stories.
In navigating the intersection of her fiction and real-world views, Rowling has not hesitated to use her platform to address political issues and defend the moral legacy of the world she created.
An avid book reader and proud library card holder, Angela is new to the world of e-Readers. She has a background in education, emergency response, fitness, loves to be in nature, traveling and exploring. With an honours science degree in anthropology, Angela also studied writing after graduation. She has contributed work to The London Free Press, The Gazette, The Londoner, Best Version Media, Lifeliner, and Citymedia.ca.
