Classic Tomato Sandwich – Spend With Pennies

August 24, 2024

20

It’s not that you need a recipe for a tomato sandwich, but honestly, I’m sharing this to make sure you don’t forget to savor one with those perfect summer tomatoes.

A classic tomato sandwich is nothing more than soft bread, juicy tomatoes with salt, pepper, and a smear of creamy mayonnaise. Perfection.

Classic Tomato Sandwich with mayonnaise on the sandwich and on a knife

Classic Tomato Sandwich – Spend With Pennies

They taste so darn good.
They’re the perfect simple meal for slices of juicy tomatoes.
They’re easy to make for a quick snack or a light summer supper.

bread , mayonnaise , tomatoes , salt and pepper with labels to make Classic Tomato Sandwich

Ingredients in Tomato Sandwiches

Tomatoes: Big sandwiches call for big tomatoes! I love heirloom tomatoes or Beefsteak tomatoes, but honestly, any ripe, juicy variety works.

Bread: White sandwich bread is classic for soaking up all that fresh tomato juice. Swap out the white bread for sourdough or thick slices of brioche.

Mayonnaise: Use a good quality mayo like Duke’s mayonnaise or Hellmanns.

Seasonings: Sprinkle a little salt and pepper, lemon pepper, or everything bagel seasoning on the tomatoes before assembling a tomato sandwich – anything goes!

Variations

You can add variations but I do think the best tomato sandwich is kept simple.

Roasted tomatoes are juicy and great over toast.
Tomatoes marinated in oil, vinegar, and basil also make a tasty sandwich.
Serve it open-faced on ricotta toast with a fried egg and a slice of bacon for a yummy breakfast, or turn it into a BLT.
Add fresh basil, red onion, lettuce, or cheese.

bread with mayonnaise to make Classic Tomato Sandwich

How to Make a Tomato Sandwich

As much as a love a BLT, this sandwich is truly one of the best ways to enjoy fresh summer tomatoes!

Cut tomatoes and place them on clean paper towels.
Season tomatoes with salt and black pepper.
Spread mayo on each slice of bread and layer tomatoes on top.
Top with a second slice of bread and cut in half before serving.

The key to a perfect tomato sandwich is cutting the slices with a serrated knife, creating clean, uniform slices.

Draining tomatoes on a paper towel helps absorb the excess moisture and helps to prevent a soggy sandwich.

More Garden Tomatoes?

Did you enjoy this Classic Tomato Sandwich Recipe? Be sure to leave a comment and rating below.

Classic Tomato Sandwich

A classic Southern tomato sandwich is simple perfection in every bite.

Prep Time 8 minutes

Total Time 8 minutes

Cook ModePrevent your screen from going dark

Use a serrated knife to cut tomatoes into thick ½-inch slices.
Place the tomato slices on a paper towel for 1-2 minutes to soak up some of the moisture. Season with salt and pepper.
Meanwhile, spread mayonnaise onto one side of each piece of bread.
Layer tomatoes onto half of the bread slices. Place remaining bread slices on top.
Cut sandwiches in half and serve immediately.

Nutrition information provided is an estimate and will vary based on cooking methods and brands of ingredients used.

Course Lunch, Sandwich, Snack

Cuisine American

© SpendWithPennies.com. Content and photographs are copyright protected. Sharing of this recipe is both encouraged and appreciated. Copying and/or pasting full recipes to any social media is strictly prohibited. Please view my photo use policy here.