Olympics fans left divided after Team USA high-jumper Shelby McEwen refused to share his gold medal with competitor – before being dealt ‘instant karma’

American high jumper Shelby McEwen divided fans on Saturday when he opted against splitting gold with New Zealand’s Hamish Kerr at the 2024 Olympics in Paris.

‘Couldn’t understand his decision and in the end it costed (sic) him the gold,’ wrote on fan after McEwen fell to Kerr in a jump-off.

Others agreed with McEwen’s ultimately doomed decision to go into a jump off to decide first and second place.

‘He wanted to be Olympic champion, not joint Olympic champion,’ one fan added. ‘I respect it.’

And it wasn’t just McEwen who wanted the jump-off. Kerr agreed (‘We both just nodded and off we went,’ he said later) but fans have remained fixated on McEwen’s end of the deal after the American came away with silver. 

Silver medallist US’ Shelby McEwen celebrates competing in the men’s high jump final

Men’s high jump gold medalist, Hamish Kerr, of New Zealand, centre, silver medalist, Shelby McEwen, left, of the United States, and bronze medalist Mutaz Essa Barshim

‘Why would anyone take the risk to lose gold?’ asked one fan on X in response to a post about McEwen. 

‘He shot his best shot,’ another added. ‘No shame in that.’ 

And in the words of Kerr, off they went. 

First they put the bar up higher. Then they lowered it. Wherever they put the bar, McEwen and Kerr couldn’t clear it. The two high jumpers, who could have decided to tie and both get a gold medal, instead put fans through an interminable jump-off for the gold at the Paris Olympics on Saturday. 

The two men had 11 straight misses – so many that there wasn´t enough room on the scoreboard for all the Xs – in regulation and the jump-off. The bar was lowered twice during the jump-off, and Kerr finally broke the streak of failures when he got over 2.34 meters (7 feet, 8 inches) to take the gold.

‘To do it the way I did it was just amazing,’ Kerr said. ‘It was crazy.’

McEwen was left with the silver, both he and Kerr having cleared 2.36 (7 feet, 8.75 inches).

Going into the Olympics final day, China led the U.S. in gold medals 39 to 38. If McEwen accepted a tie for gold, the two superpowers would be even.

At the Tokyo Olympics, a similar scenario played out and Mutaz Barshim of Qatar and Gianmarco Tamberi of Italy decided to accept the tie.

Fan reaction to McEwen’s decision was noticeably split during Saturday’s high jump final 

Second placed Shelby McEwen of USA (L) shakes hands with first placed Hamish Kerr of New Zealand (R) after the Men High Jump Final

Barshim took the bronze Saturday at 2.34. Tamberi was eliminated early on.

‘I have so much respect for what they did in Tokyo. But I always thought that to add to the story and to be able to be given the chance to actually do the jump-off would be so amazing,’ Kerr said. ‘I knew straight away that we were going to make history and we did that.

‘I´m pretty sure Shelby was in the same mindset because we just looked at each other and it was pretty simple,’ Kerr added. ‘We both just nodded and off we went.’

Added McEwen, ‘We talked to each other, and he was like, ‘Let’s jump off.’ And I was like, ‘I’m all for it.’

Kerr celebrated by running around the field in the center of the Stade de France deliriously.

They both missed at 2.38 in the first round of the jump-off, another two misses at 2.36 and McEwen missed at 2.34 before Kerr finally ended the first competition of the night only moments before the women´s 4×400 relay concluded the last session of track and field at the Stade de France.

Shelby McEwen of Team United States competes in the Men’s High Jump Fina

‘If I hadn’t cleared that jump or one very soon, we probably still would be out there,’ Kerr said.

McEwen said he thought ‘we both got a little fatigued there at the end,’ adding that he was thinking about the $50,000 prize for first place. ‘Most definitely, I got a family to feed. But, hey, we´re going to get back to the drawing boards and get better.’

Earlier, Tamberi failed on all three of his attempts at 2.27 – only the second height of the competition. He covered his face with his hands in disappointment and then Barshim came over to console his good friend.

Tamberi had been bothered by a series of physical issues over the last few days. He was hospitalized due to kidney stones and had a fever of 38.8 Celsius (101.8 Fahrenheit). But he vowed to compete no matter what.

When it was over, and Tamberi had finished 11th in the 12-man final, he went over and cried with his team in the stands.